Sinners & Saints

Toward a Reformed Political Ethic – Part One

by

Running time: (not available)

Download MP3

Yes, politics. This is part one of a very brief, whet-your-appetite-for-further-study series on how to begin answering political questions from the biblical, Reformed perspective. Here, we critique “theonomy” in order to lay the foundation for answering political questions from Scripture.

7 comments so far

  1. Perhaps one of the best critiques of theonomy I’ve heard. I plan to listen frequently.

    Tom Skerritt,
    Toronto, ON.

  2. I am still a little confused when it comes to understanding both theonomy and/or natural law.

    I understand the problems with theonomy, but what I don’t understand is why some would go so far and say that a vote against gay marriage is a theonomic stance. (Even though the state has no power to define marriage, they just want to think they do)

    Can I argue the existence of God in the political world and still be able to consider myself a natural law type? I feel this is a key issue for me and many others. I feel that with the absence of God in the political world, there is no argument for peoples rights.

  3. I don’t know that any of us said a vote against gay marriage is theonomic, perhaps you may be referring to someone else. One could vote against gay marriage for a host of reasons, not the least of reasons might include the one that says the government has no business licensing marriages at all.

    The key issue in your gay marriage debate reference is that the government has no business defining a marriage. Marriages have always been defined and contracted within communities whether that be the family, the church, or some other religious order.

    As for using rational arguments for the existence of God to in turn posit God as the basis for moral order in society, I don’t see a problem with that per say. The Declaration of Independence says that all men are endowed by their “Creator” with certain unalienable rights. In this very significant, national, founding document it sounds to me like, God is identified as the basis of human rights. So no, I don’t see a problem here. Obviously a number of other supplementing arguments and qualifications are going to be needed to clarify your position, but there does not seem to be anything inherently inconsistent with your commitment to a natural law-based political philosophy.

  4. Thanks for the response.

    I guess my main question is. Do we submit to the constitution? Or do we submit to the present state? I feel that the present state is very unconstitutional. Marriage licenses are in violation of article 1 section 10 of the constitution which says “No State shall pass any law impairing the obligation of contracts.”

    Here is the next question. Am I sinning if I legally do not get a marriage license? Or am I sinning if I do?

    Here is a great link on this topic from a lawyer in the 1800’s http://www.lysanderspooner.org/bib_new.htm

    Thanks guys!

  5. The answer is yes, we submit to the constitution and to the “present state” in all things lawful. As it stands, securing a license for marriage from the state is not something that is unlawful, that is, it is not something that violates any biblical principle.

    Are you sinning if you don’t secure a marriage license from the state? Not necessarily, as long as you entered into a binding arrangement and had that contract properly solemnized. You would want to make sure the church was well aware of what you were doing and upon what grounds though. Beyond that, you might consider the fact that your actions, if misunderstood by others, might lead to bringing reproach upon the gospel; and, if you did not take great care to avoid that, your actions, though not sinful in and of themselves, would be sinful because of the consequences they led to.

    On the whole, at this time in our nation’s history, the wisest course of action is for a believer to secure a marriage license from the state.

    Hope that helps.

  6. Very, very good. We have several people in our Reformed church who are into Vision Forum things which promote theonomy. How do you recommend we approach such people?

  7. I am interested in your response to Robert re: Vision Forum. I do not consider myself to be a theonomist, yet I do appreciate many of VF’s products. As a homeschooling mom I have found much encouragement through some of their products.

Leave a comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*


More Sinners & Saints episodes »

Subscribe to the Sinners & Saints podcast with RSS or iTunes.

Subscribe to this post with RSS.

Lessons

Free curriculum designed for your growth in Christian thinking and living.

What Is the Reformed Faith?

An introduction to the Christian worldview and the basic teachings of the Bible. Learn the basic differences among the main groups in the broad Christian tradition, and that “the Reformed faith” is just a nickname for the teachings of Jesus Christ.

Now available in iTunes.

Heidelberg Catechism Curriculum for Families

An exposition of a most treasured summary of the Bible’s basic teachings. Learn how you can be clear about the glory of Christ in His triumph over our sinful misery, so that you can pass it down to the next generation.

Now available in iTunes.

What We Believe

So that everyone visiting this website and our churches knows exactly what we believe and teach, we state our faith right alongside historic and Reformed Christian churches.

The Ecumenical Creeds

Ancient summaries of basic Bible teachings written in part to defend God’s people against heresies sadly still alive today.

The Three Forms of Unity

500-year-old summaries of basic Bible teachings written in part to defend God’s people from deep-seated theological and moral corruption in all kinds of false churches and movements.

Recent Sermons

Biblical sermons by local URC ministers

Scriptural Sermons

Rev. Tom Morrison
Matthew 21:1-17 | Jesus’ Humility

Rev. Tom Morrison
Psalm 29 | The Power and Glory of God

Rev. Tom Morrison
Psalm 1 | Be Happy

Rev. Tom Morrison
Ruth 4:1-22 | From Death to Life

Rev. Tom Morrison
Ruth 3:1-18 | Obedient Redeemer

Catechetical Sermons

Rev. Movses Janbazian
Psalm 143 | The Eyes Are On You

Rev. Movses Janbazian
Psalm 142 | Jesus’ Prayer From The Cave

Rev. Movses Janbazian
Psalm 141 | Serving As A Priest In Exile

More sermons »

Topics

Topics covered in the talk show, sermons, and lessons

More topics »

You can also find content...
...by book of the Bible
...by confession / creed

Looking for a Church? Visit these United Reformed Churches or find more churches »

Pasadena, CA
Pasadena United Reformed Church
Pastor Movses Janbazian
626-437-4994

Victorville/Apple Valley, CA
High Desert United Reformed Church
Pastor Tom Morrison
760-951-0809

Recent Comments

hr

Podcast Feeds

Sinners & Saints

Subscribe with RSS or iTunes

Rev. Movses Janbazian

Subscribe with RSS or iTunes

Rev. Adam Kaloostian

Subscribe with RSS or iTunes

Rev. Tom Morrison

Subscribe with RSS or iTunes

All posts

Subscribe with RSS or iTunes

All comments

Subscribe with RSS